Kitchen

10 Best Roasting Pans in 2018

The roasting pan is the tool of choice when it comes to cooking delicious roast beef, chicken, and numerous other oven-based recipes. The main utility of roasting pans, as opposed to normal frying pans, comes from the possibility of using a lid and a cooking rack. The best roasting pan should be made from heat-resistant materials and should have a non-stick surface. We chose the best-rated roasting pans and analyzed their materials, shape, size, and capacity, as well as their pros and cons.

10. Granite Ware Oval Roaster

This Granite Ware Roasting Pan is a great overall choice for preparing a wide variety of over-dishes, including roast beef and chicken. The roaster can hold up to 22 lbs. of poultry or another roast, which is just right for a nice family dinner. The roasting pan is made from special carbon steel, to ensure high-temperature tolerance. In addition, the surface is made of a special porcelain, which ensures a non-stick surface.

granite ware roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
oval17 x 12 x 7 inches1.3 pounds22 pounds carbon steel coated with porcelain

Pros

  • Coated with an inert, non-porous, and non-stick surface
  • No PFOA, PTFE, or other toxic or harmful chemicals
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons

  • Not as sturdy as it might look

9. Granite Ware Covered Round Roasting Pan

A very good choice for all kinds of roasts, and stews alike, the Granite Ware covered round roasting pan comes fully-equipped with a carbon steel frame and non-stick porcelain surface. It allows you to cook food more evenly, while also allowing the meat to retain various flavors. Finally, it is a dishwasher-safe product and its versatility makes it the best roasting pan for a solar cooker.

granite ware roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
round9.8 x 5.8 x 3.2 inches1.3 pounds3 poundscarbon steel with porcelain coating

Pros

  • Very compact design
  • Can also be used in a solar cooker
  • Self-basting lid

Cons

  • Very small capacity
  • Does not have handles

8. All-Clad Hard Anodized Aluminum Large Roasting Pan with Nonstick Rack

The anodized Large Roasting Pan from All-Clad is a great choice for roasting large pieces of meat and/or various cuts of chicken. The pan itself is made from a non-stick surface, maintaining this property at very high temperatures and with various types of dishes. The pan also comes equipped with a V-shaped rack, which is very useful for making crisp roast meats, with the juices collecting at the base of the pan.

all clad roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
rectangular
3.4 x 20.8 x 13.3 inches9 pounds25 poundsanodized aluminum

Pros

  • Comes with a rack
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons

  • Doesn’t come with a lid

 

7. Cook N Home Nonstick Turkey Roaster

The ultimate choice for turkey lovers, this roasting pan is the ultimate choice for cooking a delicious, nice and crisp turkey in the oven. It comes fully equipped with a non-stick surface, a V-rack and cast handles for a firm grip. In addition, the turkey roaster is also quite large and can accommodate a 25-pound turkey. It is safe for any type of cooktop, but will not work with induction heating.

cook n home roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
rectangular16 x 12 x 3 inches7 pounds25 poundsaluminum

Pros

  • Nonstick coating that is PFOA-free
  • Comes with a rack
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons

  • Cannot be used on Induction cooktops
  • Does not have a lid

 

Recommended read: Love to cook delicious meals? Then also check out our list of the best electric grills available on the market this year!

6. Calphalon Classic Hard Anodized 16-Inch Roasting Pan

The anodized Roasting Pan from Calphalon is a class above ordinary roasting pans due to its superior heat conductivity and advanced non-stick surface. This allows for cooking all types of roasts and meats while keeping cleaning nice and simple. The pan is also equipped with a nonstick rack, which is also very easy to clean. A superior roasting pan for all purposes.

calphalon roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
rectangular18.6 x 13 x 4.5 inches4.4 pounds25 poundshard anodized aluminum

Pros

  • Comes with a rack and stainless steel handles

Cons

  • The rack is not made from hard anodized aluminum and can peel after a while
  • Doesn’t have a lid

 

5. KitchenAid KC2H116RP 16″ Hard Anodized Roaster

The KitchenAid hard anodized roasting pan has an advanced non-stick surface from which you can easily clean even the most resilient burns. It comes fully equipped with a rack and comfortable handles for a firm grip. This roasting pan also stands out through its very high-temperature tolerance, being able to withstand temperatures of more than 500 degrees. A very good choice for cooking dishes which require high-temperature roasting.

kitchenaid roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
rectangular16.6 x 13.6 x 4.8 inches5.5 pounds20 poundsaluminized steel

Pros

  • PFOA/PTFE Free
  • Comes with a roasting rack that is removable
  • Dishwasher safe

Cons

  • The handles retain the heat for a long time
  • Doesn’t have a lid

 

4. Gibson Home Stainless Steel Top Roast 16-Inch Oval Roaster Pan

The Gibson stainless steel Roasting Pan is one of the best choices for holiday cooking and/or a special dinner with family and friends. The pan comes equipped with a lid and interior rack and is a great tool for cooking delicious special roasts which require a long preparation time, whether beef, chicken or turkey.

cuisine select roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
oval18.5 x 12.8 x 5.3 inches3.8 pounds22 poundsstainless steel

Pros

  • Comes with an interior rack
  • The lid has small vents that can be opened or closed

Cons

  • The lid does not sit securely on the pan

 

3. Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Stainless Rectangular Roaster

The chef’s classic rectangular roaster from Cuisinart is the best classy roasting pan you’re going to get at a fairly decent price. The exterior is made from high-quality stainless steel, resistant to high temperatures. This roasting pan can thus hold large and very large roasts, chickens or turkeys. It will perform wonderfully for any such cooking occasion. Although it got the third spot on our list, this is the best roasting pan for you if you also care about design and looks.

cuisinart roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
rectangular20.75 x 6.25 x 13.25 inches6 pounds22 poundstriple ply stainless steel

Pros

  • Well-build and sturdy construction
  • Drip-free pouring

Cons

  • Some items have discolored after a few uses
  • Doesn’t come with a lid

 

2. Granite Ware 0511-3 Covered Rectangular Roaster 21.25 by 14 by 8.5-Inch

This piece of cookery equipment from Granite Ware stands out from the rest due to its large size, excellent heat distribution and heat resistance. Its large size will accommodate the largest roast. Moreover, its carbon steel construction and non-stick surface make handling and cleaning easy. Finally, its accessible price also makes it a great budget choice to equip your kitchen. This is the second best roasting pan on this list, but the one on the first spot is made by the same company.

granite ware roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
rectangular21.2 x 14 x 8.5 inches4.7 pounds25 poundsporcelain coated carbon steel

Pros

  • Dishwasher safe
  • Large, sturdy, and long-lasting pan

Cons

  • Can scald the hands in hot steam because of the side handles of the lid

 

1. Granite Ware 0509 18-Inch Covered Oval Roaster

Combining versatility, resilience, and cost-effectiveness, the Granite Ware 0509 Oval Roaster is the best choice for any type of roast. The pan is of excellent quality, with a carbon steel core, porcelain surface and a very well designed lid. This allows for aroma and steam retention. Its extreme durability, combined with a highly accessible price, make this roasting pan the very best out there. It is a must have item for your kitchen and it’s the best roasting pan on this list.

granite ware roasting pan

ShapeSizeWeightCapacityMaterials
oval19 x 13.5 x 4.75 inches 3.5 pounds22 poundsporcelain-coated carbon steel

Pros

  • Safe and long-lasting porcelain coating
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Comes with a lid

Cons

  • Doesn’t come with a rack

 

Conclusion

All in all, the best roasting pan is made by Granite Ware who managed to take up more than one spot in our top due to their reliability and porcelain-coated carbon steel construction. The Cuisinart option, however, is another good choice thanks to its sturdy construction.

Do you have a favorite roasting pan that was not included on this list? Give us the details in the comments!

Leave a Comment